Ontario Rent to Own Homes Directory
Menu
Find your home

The Polsinello Real Estate Team

Updated 2026-10-30 · 3,954 reviewed · 238 listed · Scored from 1,222 Google reviews · How we rank ›

5.0(1222) 95 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Rent-to-Own Home ProgramsLease Option & Lease-to-OwnRent-to-Own New Builds & Condos
The Polsinello Real Estate Team
Location
Newmarket
Services
Rent-to-Own Home Programs, Lease Option & Lease-to-Own, Rent-to-Own New Builds & Condos
Reviews
1222
Ranking
#1 in Rent-to-Own Home Programs
Best for
people wanting responsive agents who explain each step

Business data from Google Business Profile, checked 2026-10-30. Facts from the business's own website were fetched 2026-10-30.

Compare: Polsinello Real Estate Team vs Flinnco Property Management: lease option and lease-to-ownPolsinello Real Estate Team vs Trusted Property Solutions: rent-to-own fit

What recent reviews say

Across 1222 Google reviews, the team averages 5 stars, and the last 19 reviews are all four or five stars. Reviewers often describe agents who reply fast, explain each step, and let clients decide without pressure. Many praise the team's market knowledge and attention to showings and schedules.

Recent reviews cover buying, selling, and renting out property in the Newmarket area and beyond. Several name individual agents, including Jodi McGuirk, Conor, Brandon Polsinello, and Dan Mladjenovic. Some mention staging help, weekly email updates, and drone photos. The business says it covers York Region and Toronto.

Praised for
  • quick replies and easy access
  • patient, clear explanations of each step
  • no pressure to decide
  • knowledgeable about the local market
  • attentive to showings and client schedules
responsiveknowledgeablehonestsmooth-processfirst-time-buyers
Best for: people wanting responsive agents who explain each step

Where this business shines

  • quick replies and easy access
  • clear explanations at each step
  • team support with staging and listing photos
  • agents named in reviews for buying and selling

Worth knowing

  • Reviewers name agents Jodi McGuirk, Conor, Brandon Polsinello, Dan Mladjenovic, and Josh Wannamaker
  • Staging visit and drone photo shoot mentioned for one listing
  • Weekly email updates mentioned by one client
  • Website lists a Love It or Leave It guarantee for buyers
  • Website lists paid listing marketing: photography, video walk-through, aerial video, and laser-measured floor plans

What reviews say by service

Rent-to-Own Home Programs
Reviews focus on buying, selling, and leasing, not rent-to-own deals specifically.

How it compares

  • Rated 5 against a 4.5 average across the 176 rent-to-own home programs businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 99% of the businesses in this directory.

What earned this score?

Scoring Method
Star rating 99
Review volume 100
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 81
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
1213
4
4
3
0
2
1
1
4

Common questions

Does the team handle rentals as well as sales?
Yes. Reviewers describe the team finding tenants for condo units and leasing out existing properties.
Which areas does the team serve?
The website says it serves York Region, Toronto, parts of Peel and Halton, and several other areas.
Request a quote

Similar rent to own home providers nearby

Wasim Jarrah-Concierge Realty Group
89

Wasim Jarrah-Concierge Realty Group

4.9(112)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers describe a team that answers questions fast and keeps clients updated at each step. Many say agents Marlen, Milad and Wasim stay patient and calm, even in competitive markets. Several long-time clients say they return to the same people for each new deal. Recent reviews cover home sales, purchases and rentals across the Newmarket and York Region area. Reviewers mention organized written plans, multiple property options, and extra help such as garage sales after a closing. One charity client also praised the team's support on a sublease.

Rent-to-Own New Builds & CondosRent-to-Own Home Programs
View profile
Dave Mitchell - Main Street Realty Ltd
55 low data

Dave Mitchell - Main Street Realty Ltd

5.0(5)✓ Google-verified

Five Google reviews, all five-star, describe agent Dave Mitchell helping with home sales and purchases across York Region. Reviews are older, with the newest about seven years old. Detail is limited.

Rent-to-Own Home ProgramsRent-to-Own New Builds & Condos
View profile
Main Street Realty Ltd.
65 low data

Main Street Realty Ltd.

4.0(18)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Reviews are mixed and the evidence is thin. Recent five-star reviews praise agents for being knowledgeable and professional. Older one-star reviews describe unresponsive staff and a buyer deal that went badly.

Rent-to-Own Home ProgramsRent-to-Own New Builds & Condos
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-10-30